Prince (2007)

This was hands down the most iconic Super Bowl performance in recent history - and we say that with confidence. It's no secret that Prince was a great performer but he truly exceeded all expectations with this one. I mean, he did a bloody Foo Fighters cover for crying out loud - no one saw that coming. And then he broke into an epic guitar solo in the middle of Purple Rain, all in the midst of a torrential rainstorm in Miami. That's talent.