Quantcast

Alternatives to Impeaching Donald Trump

The magnitude and variety of President Donald Trump's sins of commission and omission suggest that once special counsel Robert Mueller finishes his report and his indictments, there will be ample grounds to conclude that the president abused his power and violated his oath. We think a majority of House members in good conscience (which would mean Republicans), when all the facts are in and his efforts to undermine the Russia investigation are laid out, could find that his conduct met the standard for impeachment. It's important to draw a line in the sand, to tell future presidents what is acceptable and what is not. The downside of a symbolic impeachment (or even a successful one) is serious and far-reaching. The constant fights will be corrosive and make governance in the future even more problematic. Trump supporters will claim the
    0     0     0
The magnitude and variety of President Donald Trump's sins of commission and omission suggest that once special counsel Robert Mueller finishes his report and his indictments, there will be ample grounds to conclude that the president abused his power and violated his oath. We think a majority of House members in good conscience (which would mean Republicans), when all the facts are in and his efforts to undermine the Russia investigation are laid out, could find that his conduct met the standard for impeachment. It's important to draw a line in the sand, to tell future presidents what is acceptable and what is not.

The downside of a symbolic impeachment (or even a successful one) is serious and far-reaching. The constant fights will be corrosive and make governance in the future even more problematic. Trump supporters will claim the "establishment" took him down and overrode the will of the people.

What other options may we have?

Refresh

 
An exhaustive account of not only Russian meddling and any coordination with the Trump camp, but also of any and all conflicts of interest, misleading statements, improper conduct toward women and receipt of foreign emoluments will set the record straight. We need a complete description of how this president attempted to direct the Justice Department in ways that depart from past practice and the historical separation between the Justice Department and the White House.
1 | 0.00%

An exhaustive account of not only Russian meddling and any coordination with the Trump camp, but also of any and all conflicts of interest, misleading statements, improper conduct toward women and receipt of foreign emoluments will set the record straight. We need a complete description of how this president attempted to direct the Justice Department in ways that depart from past practice and the historical separation between the Justice Department and the White House.

See all 0 comments
Expose

An exhaustive account of not only Russian meddling and any coordination with the Trump camp, but also of any and all conflicts of interest, misleading statements, improper conduct toward women and receipt of foreign emoluments will set the record straight. We need a complete description of how this president attempted to direct the Justice Department in ways that depart from past practice and the historical separation between the Justice Department and the White House.

 
A Democratic majority in either house can conduct real oversight, using the subpoena power to obtain everything from Trump's tax records to Hope Hicks' diary (if it exists). Hearings should be open to the public; phony claims of executive privilege should be dismissed. Allegations by Trump's female accusers and any hush payments should also be aired. Were any women coerced into signing false statements, as Stormy Daniels claimed she was?
2 | 0.00%

A Democratic majority in either house can conduct real oversight, using the subpoena power to obtain everything from Trump's tax records to Hope Hicks' diary (if it exists). Hearings should be open to the public; phony claims of executive privilege should be dismissed. Allegations by Trump's female accusers and any hush payments should also be aired. Were any women coerced into signing false statements, as Stormy Daniels claimed she was?

See all 0 comments
Investigate

A Democratic majority in either house can conduct real oversight, using the subpoena power to obtain everything from Trump's tax records to Hope Hicks' diary (if it exists). Hearings should be open to the public; phony claims of executive privilege should be dismissed. Allegations by Trump's female accusers and any hush payments should also be aired. Were any women coerced into signing false statements, as Stormy Daniels claimed she was?

 
Congress can require presidents to disclose their tax returns. Congress also can require presidents to divest of their active businesses, toughen anti-nepotism laws, prevent self-dealing (profiting from the presidency while in office) and limit taxpayer reimbursement for personal travel (e.g., back and forth to Trump's properties). If Trump chooses to maintain financial secrecy and hold onto his businesses rather than remain in the presidency, that's his choice.
3 | 0.00%

Congress can require presidents to disclose their tax returns. Congress also can require presidents to divest of their active businesses, toughen anti-nepotism laws, prevent self-dealing (profiting from the presidency while in office) and limit taxpayer reimbursement for personal travel (e.g., back and forth to Trump's properties). If Trump chooses to maintain financial secrecy and hold onto his businesses rather than remain in the presidency, that's his choice.

See all 0 comments
Legislate

Congress can require presidents to disclose their tax returns. Congress also can require presidents to divest of their active businesses, toughen anti-nepotism laws, prevent self-dealing (profiting from the presidency while in office) and limit taxpayer reimbursement for personal travel (e.g., back and forth to Trump's properties). If Trump chooses to maintain financial secrecy and hold onto his businesses rather than remain in the presidency, that's his choice.

 
Congress can take up a motion of censure, if it finds he has behaved in ways that have disgraced the office. This reinforces standards of conduct and serves as a guide to future presidents.
4 | 0.00%

Congress can take up a motion of censure, if it finds he has behaved in ways that have disgraced the office. This reinforces standards of conduct and serves as a guide to future presidents.

See all 0 comments
Censure

Congress can take up a motion of censure, if it finds he has behaved in ways that have disgraced the office. This reinforces standards of conduct and serves as a guide to future presidents.

 
If Trump is found to have committed illegal actions, he can be prosecuted after leaving office. A Democratic successor (maybe even a Republican one) would be unlikely to pardon him. (He can try pardoning himself, but that, I strongly suspect, will not hold up in court.)
5 | 0.00%

If Trump is found to have committed illegal actions, he can be prosecuted after leaving office. A Democratic successor (maybe even a Republican one) would be unlikely to pardon him. (He can try pardoning himself, but that, I strongly suspect, will not hold up in court.)

See all 0 comments
Prosecute

If Trump is found to have committed illegal actions, he can be prosecuted after leaving office. A Democratic successor (maybe even a Republican one) would be unlikely to pardon him. (He can try pardoning himself, but that, I strongly suspect, will not hold up in court.)

 
If Trump is still in office after all that, the voters get a chance to render their verdict in 2020. That is as it should be. The peaceful transfer of power once again can take place.
6 | 0.00%

If Trump is still in office after all that, the voters get a chance to render their verdict in 2020. That is as it should be. The peaceful transfer of power once again can take place.

See all 0 comments
Defeat (Vote)

If Trump is still in office after all that, the voters get a chance to render their verdict in 2020. That is as it should be. The peaceful transfer of power once again can take place.

 
None of those may be as emotionally satisfying as impeachment, but it may provide what we badly need as a country — consensus on facts, closure and a new code of presidential conduct. Moreover, he will be held accountable — by Congress and by the voters. And if anyone doubts how much Trump fears all that scrutiny and exposure, just consider how adamant he has been about concealing his tax records.
7 | 0.00%

None of those may be as emotionally satisfying as impeachment, but it may provide what we badly need as a country — consensus on facts, closure and a new code of presidential conduct. Moreover, he will be held accountable — by Congress and by the voters. And if anyone doubts how much Trump fears all that scrutiny and exposure, just consider how adamant he has been about concealing his tax records.

See all 0 comments
Other

None of those may be as emotionally satisfying as impeachment, but it may provide what we badly need as a country — consensus on facts, closure and a new code of presidential conduct. Moreover, he will be held accountable — by Congress and by the voters. And if anyone doubts how much Trump fears all that scrutiny and exposure, just consider how adamant he has been about concealing his tax records.

Refresh