Broadway Super-Gang

When it was announced that Corden would host theater’s biggest night, most of his loyal viewers had a feeling a super-packed Carpool Karaoke was on its way. Sure enough, Corden delivered: Lin-Manuel Miranda, Audra McDonald, Jesse Tyler Ferguson, and Jane Krakowski piled into the car to sing songs from classics like Les Miserables and newer hits like, of course, Hamilton. The group’s final number—a riveting rendition of “One Day More”—could have earned a spot on this list on its own.

Broadway Super-Gang is found in...